AS Daily A Level Physics question
Two identical balls are released from a balcony 5.0 m above level ground at the same instant. Ball P is dropped from rest. Ball Q is projected horizontally at 8.0 m/s. Air resistance is negligible. Which statement must be true when they strike the ground?
Answer
The correct answer is A.
Correct: A — They reach the ground together; their vertical velocity components are equal and downward, but Q’s overall speed is about 1.3 times P’s. A Both have identical vertical motion (same height, initial vertical speed zero), so equal landing times and equal downward vertical components; P’s impact speed ≈ sqrt(2gh) ≈ 9.9 m/s, Q’s ≈ sqrt(9.9^2 + 8.0^2) ≈ 12.7 m/s, so about 1.3× larger. B Horizontal motion does not affect the time to fall, and the overall speeds are not equal because Q has an additional horizontal component. C The vertical component is set by the fall alone, so it is not larger for Q; having a greater total speed does not increase the vertical component. D Extra horizontal speed does not make Q land sooner, and P’s final speed cannot exceed Q’s because Q has the same vertical component plus a horizontal component.