Back to Daily Question archive

A2 Daily A Level Physics question

2025-10-05 OCR A Thermal physics I: internal energy; specific heat; energy changes; heating curves (qual.) 5.1.3(a)

Two 1.0 kg samples, one aluminium and one water, start at the same temperature. Each is heated by an identical 200 W heater for 100 s. The specific heat capacity of water is four times that of aluminium. Which statement must be true about their temperature rises after 100 s? Give a reason.

  1. A They increase by the same amount, because both receive the same energy.
  2. B Water’s temperature increase is four times aluminium’s, because water has the larger specific heat capacity.
  3. C Aluminium’s temperature increase is four times water’s, because with equal mass and energy, temperature rise is inversely proportional to specific heat. (correct)
  4. D Aluminium’s temperature increase is sixteen times water’s, because the ratio combines with the equal power and time.

Answer

The correct answer is C.

Correct: C — Aluminium’s temperature increase is four times water’s, because with equal mass and energy, temperature rise is inversely proportional to specific heat. A ignores that the same energy shared by a substance with larger specific heat gives a smaller temperature rise, not the same. B reverses the relationship: higher specific heat means smaller temperature rise for the same energy and mass, not larger. C is correct since ΔT ∝ 1/c, so ΔT_Al/ΔT_water = c_water/c_Al = 4. D incorrectly squares the factor and invokes power/time even though they are the same for both, so they cancel in the ratio.