Waves QWC practice question
Question
Two identical cans are painted matt black and shiny silver. Explain how a fair experiment could compare their cooling rates and why the surface finish affects the results. [6 marks]
Student guidance
Separate the fair-test method from the infrared explanation.
Expected physics points
- Put equal masses of water at the same starting temperature in identical cans.
- Measure temperature at regular times with the same thermometer or data logger.
- Keep room conditions, can size, water volume and timing the same.
- Repeat measurements and plot temperature against time or compare cooling rates.
- Matt black surfaces are better emitters of infrared radiation than shiny surfaces.
- The black can should transfer energy faster and cool more quickly; shiny surfaces are poorer emitters/reflectors.
Mark scheme points
- Uses equal masses of water at the same starting temperature in identical cans.
- Measures temperature at regular times with the same instrument.
- Controls room conditions, can size, water volume and timing.
- Repeats and plots temperature against time or compares cooling rates.
- Matt black is a better infrared emitter than a shiny surface.
- The black can transfers energy faster; shiny surfaces are poorer emitters or reflectors.
Indicative content
- Put equal masses of water at the same starting temperature in identical cans.
- Measure temperature at regular times with the same thermometer or data logger.
- Keep room conditions, can size, water volume and timing the same.
- Repeat measurements and plot temperature against time or compare cooling rates.
- Matt black surfaces are better emitters of infrared radiation than shiny surfaces.
- The black can should transfer energy faster and cool more quickly; shiny surfaces are poorer emitters/reflectors.
Want feedback on your own written answer? Try this question in guest QWC practice.
Browse problem-solving question previews or use the Daily Question archive.