A2 Daily A Level Physics question
In a lab test, a DC source with some internal resistance is connected to resistive loads. With a 6.0 Ω load, the voltmeter across the load reads 9.0 V. Replacing it with a 3.0 Ω load, the voltmeter reads 8.0 V. Assume the source parameters are constant. Which statement must be true?
Answer
The correct answer is B.
Correct: B — The source’s emf is about 10.3 V and its internal resistance about 0.86 Ω; a short circuit would draw roughly 12 A. A treats the highest terminal pd as the emf and proposes an r that cannot reproduce both readings (with E = 9.0 V neither load gives 9.0 V at the terminals). B uses the change in terminal voltage (1.0 V) and change in current (8/3 − 1.5 A ≈ 1.167 A) to obtain r ≈ 1.0/1.167 ≈ 0.86 Ω, then E ≈ 9.0 + 1.5r ≈ 10.3 V, giving short‑circuit current E/r ≈ 12 A. C assumes terminal pd scales directly with external resistance; with internal resistance this is false and the quoted r and E contradict the two measurements. D reverses the limiting case: as load resistance → 0, terminal pd → 0 while current → E/r (here much larger than 3 A); the claimed r < 0.40 Ω is also incompatible with a 1.0 V drop when current increases by about 1.17 A.