Back to problem-solving questions

Oscillations problem-solving question

OCR A Olympiad 5.3.1(c)(i) 5.3.1(d) 5.3.1(e) 5.3.2(a)

Question

A "magnetic spring" is constructed using two identical small neodymium magnets. One magnet is fixed to the base of a vertical glass tube. The second magnet, of mass $m = 12.0\text{ g}$, is placed inside the tube such that it is repelled by the fixed magnet and levitates at an equilibrium height $h_0$ above it. The repulsive force $F_m$ between the magnets can be modelled by the power law $F_m = \frac{k}{h^n}$, where $h$ is the separation between the centers of the magnets, $k$ is a constant related to the magnetic strength, and $n$ is a dimensionless exponent. (a) At equilibrium, the levitating magnet is at $h_0 = 4.50\text{ cm}$. If the magnet is displaced slightly by a distance $x$ from equilibrium ($x \ll h_0$), show that the resulting motion is approximately simple harmonic and derive an expression for the angular frequency $\omega$ in terms of $n, g,$ and $h_0$. [4] (b) An experimenter measures the period of small vertical oscillations to be $T = 0.350\text{ s}$. Using this data, determine the value of the exponent $n$. [4] (c) The magnet is now pushed down to a height $h_{min} = 3.00\text{ cm}$ and released from rest. Assuming the power law remains valid and ignoring air resistance, calculate the maximum height $h_{max}$ reached by the magnet. [6] (d) In a real setup, the magnet experiences a damping force $F_d = -bv$, where $v$ is the velocity. It is observed that after 10 full oscillations, the amplitude of the motion reduces by 40%. Calculate the damping constant $b$ in $\text{kg s}^{-1}$. [4] (e) If the base of the tube is now vibrated vertically with a very small amplitude $A_{drive}$ at a frequency of $2.86\text{ Hz}$, describe the resulting motion of the levitating magnet and explain why the amplitude of the magnet's oscillation might become unexpectedly large. [2]

Worked solution guidance

(a) The net force on the levitating magnet is $F_{net} = \frac{k}{h^n} - mg$. At equilibrium ($h=h_0$), $F_{net} = 0$, so $\frac{k}{h_0^n} = mg \implies k = mg h_0^n$. For a small displacement $x$ such that $h = h_0 + x$, the restoring force is: $F_{restoring} = \frac{k}{(h_0+x)^n} - mg = k h_0^{-n} (1 + \frac{x}{h_0})^{-n} - mg$. Using the binomial expansion $(1+\epsilon)^{-n} \approx 1 - n\epsilon$ for $\epsilon \ll 1$: $F_{restoring} \approx mg(1 - n\frac{x}{h_0}) - mg = - \frac{nmg}{h_0}x$. Since $F = ma$, we have $ma = - \frac{nmg}{h_0}x \implies a = - \frac{ng}{h_0}x$. This is the SHM equation $a = -\omega^2 x$, where $\omega = \sqrt{\frac{ng}{h_0}}$. (b) From $T = \frac{2\pi}{\omega}$, we have $T = 2\pi \sqrt{\frac{h_0}{ng}}$. Squaring both sides: $T^2 = \frac{4\pi^2 h_0}{ng}$. Rearranging for $n$: $n = \frac{4\pi^2 h_0}{g T^2}$. Substitute $h_0 = 0.045\text{ m}$, $g = 9.81\text{ m s}^{-2}$, and $T = 0.350\text{ s}$: $n = \frac{4 \times \pi^2 \times 0.045}{9.81 \times 0.350^2} = \frac{1.7765}{1.2017} \approx 1.478$. Rounding to appropriate significant figures, $n \approx 1.48$. (c) We use conservation of energy. The potential energy $U$ consists of gravitational $U_g = mgh$ and magnetic $U_m$. $F_m = -\frac{dU_m}{dh} \implies U_m = -\int \frac{k}{h^n} dh = \frac{k}{(n-1)h^{n-1}}$. Total Energy $E = mgh + \frac{mgh_0^n}{(n-1)h^{n-1}}$. At $h_{min} = 0.030\text{ m}$ and $h_{max}$, the velocity is zero, so $E(h_{min}) = E(h_{max})$. $mg h_{min} + \frac{mg h_0^n}{(n-1)h_{min}^{n-1}} = mg h_{max} + \frac{mg h_0^n}{(n-1)h_{max}^{n-1}}$. Divide by $mg$ and substitute...

Marking guidance

(a) [4 marks] - 1 mark: Equating $mg = k/h_0^n$ to find $k$. - 1 mark: Expressing net force for $h_0 + x$ and using binomial expansion correctly. - 1 mark: Identifying the form $a = -Cx$ and stating $C = \omega^2$. - 1 mark: Correct final expression $\omega = \sqrt{ng/h_0}$. (b) [4 marks] - 1 mark: Correct relationship between $T$ and $\omega$. - 1 mark: Rearranging for $n$ algebraically. - 1 mark: Correct substitution of all values in SI units. - 1 mark: Final value $n \approx 1.48$ (accept 1.47-1.49). (c) [6 marks] - 1 mark: Correct integration of force to find magnetic potential energy $U_m \propto h^{1-n}$. - 1 mark: Statement of conservation of energy $E_{tot} = U_g + U_m$. - 1 mark: Correct expression for total energy including the $k$ constant or $mgh_0^n$ term. - 1 mark: Setting $E(h_{min}) = E(h_{max})$. - 1 mark: Numerical calculation of the energy constant (approx 0.144m in head units). - 1 mark: Solving for $h_{max} \approx 6.48\text{ cm}$ (accept 6.4-6.6 cm). (d) [4...

Hints

(a) Hint 1: Start by writing the net force $F = F_{mag} - mg$. At equilibrium, this is zero. Hint 2: When the magnet moves to $h_0 + x$, the magnetic force becomes $k(h_0+x)^{-n}$. Use the binomial theorem $(1+\epsilon)^p \approx 1 + p\epsilon$. Hint 3: Compare your resulting acceleration equation to the standard SHM form $a = -\omega^2 x$. (b) Hint 1: Use the standard formula relating period $T$ to angular frequency $\omega$. Hint 2: Substitute the expression for $\omega$ from part (a) into the period formula. Hint 3: Make sure all units are in SI (meters and seconds) before calculating $n$. (c) Hint 1: This is not SHM because the displacement is large (not $x \ll h_0$). You must use...

Want feedback on your own attempt? Try this question in guest ProblemBOT.

Use MCQs for quick retrieval practice or browse the Daily Question archive.